TaubmanSucks.com
WillowBendSucks.com
WillowBendMallSucks.com
ShopsAtWillowBendSucks.com
TheShopsAtWillowBendSucks.com
GiffordKrassGrohSprinkleSucks.com

[ Home Page | Condensed Version | The Movie | The Book | News | Blogs | Feedback / Mail List ]


Act 38: Taubman Opposes My Jurisdiction Challenge

Strictly for procedural reasons, Ms. Greenberg is opposing my motion to dismiss the case for lack of personal jurisdiction.


UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION

THE TAUBMAN COMPANY LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, Plaintiff,

v. WEBFEATS and HENRY MISHKOFF,
Defendants.

Civil Action No. 01-72987
Honorable Lawrence P. Zatkoff
Magistrate Judge Komives


PLAINTIFF'S BRIEF OPPOSING MOTION TO DISMISS
FOR LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION

This motion must be denied as untimely and in violation of the Federal Rules. Defendants previously filed a motion to change venue in this case, which has been fully briefed, and even refiled (pursuant to the Court's order that it be brought into compliance with the local rules). Neither the original motion to change venue, nor the refiled version, made any mention of personal jurisdiction. Pursuant to the Federal Rules, this successor motion, based as it is on lack of personal jurisdiction, is prohibited.

Rule 12(g) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provides:

    If a party makes a motion under this rule but omits therefrom any defense or objection then available to the party which this rule permits to be raised by motion, the party shall not thereafter make a motion based on the defense so omitted, except a motion as provided in subdivision h(2) hereof on any of the grounds there stated. [subsection h(2) refers to the defense of failure to state a claim]. (Emphasis added).

See, Albany Ins. Co. v. Almacenadora Somex, S.A., 5 F.3d 907,909 (5th Cir. 1993) ("The meaning of subdivision (g) is clear. If a party seeks dismissal in a pretrial motion based on any of the defenses set out in Rule 12(b), he must include in such motion any other defense or objection then available which Rule 12 permits to be raised by motion.") See generally, 2 Moore's Federal Practice 3d §12.21 (1997).

Defendants did not mention the grounds of personal jurisdiction in either venue motion filed, and are precluded from bringing the instant motion by Rule 12(g).

Throughout these proceedings, Defendants have repeatedly requested forbearance from the Court with respect to their failure to comply with the Federal Rules. However, the Court has informed Defendants of the complex nature of these proceedings, and of the advisability of securing legal counsel. Defendants have elected to forge ahead pro se. They should not be permitted to continue to benefit by failing to adhere to the requirements of the Federal Rules. Pursuant to the express provisions of Rule 12(g), this Court should dismiss this motion as prohibited.

In the event the Court does not deny this motion pursuant to Rule 12(g) as set forth above, Plaintiff respectfully requests an opportunity to respond further to the merits of Defendants' defense of lack of personal jurisdiction.

Respectfully submitted,

Julie A. Greenberg (P38299)
GIFFORD, KRASS, GROH, SPRINKLE,
ANDERSON & CITKOWSKI, P.C.
280 N. Old Woodward Ave., Suite 400
Birmingham, Michigan 48009
(248)647-6000

Attorneys for Plaintiff

Dated: 11-27-01

View the Original Brief (in a separate window)


Did you catch her snide little comment? If not, allow me to call it to your attention:

    "Defendants have elected to forge ahead pro se."

So basically, anyone who can't afford a lawyer is guilty of willful obstinacy! Because I don't want to shell out thousands of dollars to hire an attorney to defend myself from her harassment, I've become the object of Ms. Greenberg's sarcasm and scorn. This is the nastiest kind of class warfare – I stand accused of being too poor to afford the kind of ridiculously overpriced legal services that Ms. Greenberg provides for her wealthy corporate clients.

Next: Scheduling Order

[ Home Page | Condensed Version | The Movie | The Book | News | Blogs | Feedback / Mail List ]

©2001 Hank Mishkoff
All rights reserved.